Comment rules
Hard scrutiny is the point of this place. The one line is stating wrongdoing as fact without evidence.
Welcome here
- Challenge the numbers. Ask how a metric was measured, what's excluded, and over what period.
- Share your own experience with the product, the category, or a similar deal.
- Disagree with the maker directly — they get a right of reply, not a veto.
Not allowed
- Stating wrongdoing as fact without evidence. If you believe a listing is fraudulent, report it — that route is confidential and it gets investigated.
- Personal attacks on the maker rather than the claims in the listing.
- Taking the conversation off-platform to work around the deal process.
The maker's right of reply
The maker or seller of a listing can reply under any criticism, and that reply is pinned directly beneath it. Right of reply means exactly that — not a right of removal. No maker can hide or delete a comment.
If something is serious
Report it instead of commenting. Reports are confidential, reviewed by a person, and if a decision goes against you it can be appealed — always by someone other than the original decision-maker.